pcsoft.us.windevCopyright 2026, PC SOFT7 Aug 2017 19:56:00 Z2 Aug 2017 23:10:00 ZAl wrote in 2012: "The other thing I have found with the For All syntax is that it doesn't always work if the action you take inside the loop writes to the file being scanned, so if your Do_The_Deed code writes to the OrderItem file it can cause it to go to the end of the file and close out of the For All loop." http://27130.foren.mysnip.de/read.php?27131,133147,133156#msg-133156 (bolding is mine) Well, no improvement in this respect. The same problem still exists in WD21; the code doesn't do what it is supposed to do, it just slips through the loop doing nothing... The workaround for this is to use instead a HReadFirst - HReadNext structure to do the deed. Best regards Ola PCSoft's motto: "Why fix old bugs when it's much more fun creating new ones":eek:30WEBDEVen_UShttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented/read.awpmoderateur@pcsoft.fr (El moderador)webmaster@pcsoft.fr (El webmaster)guestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62136/read.awp7 Aug 2017 19:56:00 ZQuote Art Bonds And Russ Eggan said "If it's not there, you don't need it!" Yup, that was more or less the case :) And…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62136/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62136/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62148/read.awp7 Aug 2017 16:02:00 ZQuote Tor-Bjarne I had for each in Progress 4gl years ago and liked it, was actually my first posting on the Clarion for…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62148/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62148/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62106/read.awp5 Aug 2017 19:25:00 ZHi Peter, I just have to underscore what Fabrice is saying. In the last 15 years we wrote quite a lot of very complex WINDEV …https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62106/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62106/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62105/read.awp5 Aug 2017 15:58:00 ZHi Fabrice, As an example: try to consume standard SharePoint webservices out of WX including ComplexType xml elements. Undoa…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62105/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62105/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62102/read.awp5 Aug 2017 13:41:00 ZHi Peter, Quote Peter Holemans I had to learn it the hard way. Been there done that for more than 17 years. I just hi…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62102/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62102/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62103/read.awp5 Aug 2017 00:11:00 ZQuote Fabrice The "for all" seem to be in the categories of things they had to add for people coming from another language t…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62103/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62103/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62093/read.awp4 Aug 2017 17:22:00 ZQuote Fabrice And for those of you who don't know me yet, I DO like to be in control when I code Hi Fabrice, Agree co…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62093/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62093/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62092/read.awp4 Aug 2017 16:15:00 ZHi Tor Bjarne Nope For each string s1 of Str2 Loop+extractstring for each ds of data source Hreadfirst/next for …https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62092/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62092/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62085/read.awp4 Aug 2017 10:34:00 ZQuote Fabrice I personnaly NEVER use the FOR ALL syntax. For each string s1 of Str2 for each ds of data source for each…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62085/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62085/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62087/read.awp3 Aug 2017 17:44:00 ZHi Ola, As Peter has already said, I always use a query and then use FOR EACH... to work through the result set.https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62087/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62087/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62073/read.awp3 Aug 2017 13:41:00 ZHi Ola, BE CAREFUL! You will have the exact same problem with a hreadfirst, hreadnext, if you modify the order of the key …https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62073/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62073/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62072/read.awp3 Aug 2017 11:50:00 ZModifying multiple records IN A LOOP usually indicates that all valid records will be updated with the same values. In this cas…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62072/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62072/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62071/read.awp3 Aug 2017 10:40:00 ZHi all, Thanks for the comments. I use FOR ALL a lot, especially when there is mostly just a few records to be handled. It's …https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62071/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62071/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62070/read.awp3 Aug 2017 09:38:00 ZHi Ola, Tip: use FOR EACH on query result sets (As a matter of fact use queries in all cases). This way you can do anythin…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62070/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62070/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62069/read.awp3 Aug 2017 07:34:00 ZHi Ola, This is not really a bug, this is probably by design and the same is true for other programming languages. Even in Mi…https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62069/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62069/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documentedguestpcsoft.us.windevhttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62068/read.awp3 Aug 2017 07:10:00 ZHi Ola, you will not believe it - cannot remember a single case where I used that FOR ALL thing. The (my) good old way is to …https://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62068/read.awphttps://forum.pcsoft.fr/es-ES/pcsoft.us.windev/62066-wd21-for-all-does-not-always-work-documented-62068/read.awp[WD21] FOR ALL does not always work as documented